Home › Downtown and the Public Realm › Chapter 16

Downtown and the Public Realm

Chapter 16The Civic Square

4,672 words · Mike Seiler · Owen Sound, Ontario

In this chapter

• 16.1 Why a Civic Square
• 16.2 Start With What We Already Own
• 16.3 The Pilot-First Rule
• 16.4 A Square That Works Without an Event
• 16.5 Flexible Space
• 16.6 The Market
• 16.7 Food
• 16.8 Stage Capability
• 16.9 Power
• 16.10 Water
• 16.11 Public Washrooms
• 16.12 Accessibility
• 16.13 Accessible Events
• 16.14 Seating
• 16.15 Shade
• 16.16 Weather
• 16.17 Winter Civic Square
• 16.18 Children's Use
• 16.19 Youth Use
• 16.20 Seniors
• 16.21 Public Art
• 16.22 Music
• 16.23 Public Speaking and Debate
• 16.24 Peaceful Demonstration
• 16.25 Faith and Cultural Events
• 16.26 Indigenous Partnership
• 16.27 Markets Beyond Food
• 16.28 Local Manufacturers
• 16.29 Repair Events
• 16.30 Recreation
• 16.31 Community Organizations
• 16.32 The Community Calendar
• 16.33 Booking Rules
• 16.34 Fees
• 16.35 Commercial Use
• 16.36 Alcohol
• 16.37 Sound
• 16.38 Emergency Access
• 16.39 Loading and Setup
• 16.40 Waste
• 16.41 Storage
• 16.42 Shared Event Equipment
• 16.43 Partners
• 16.44 Sponsorship
• 16.45 No Advertising Surveillance
• 16.46 Safety
• 16.47 Lighting
• 16.48 Heritage and City Hall
• 16.49 City Hall Should Open Toward the Square
• 16.50 No Campaign Square
• 16.51 Measurement
• 16.52 Public Feedback During the Pilot
• 16.53 The First 100 Days
• 16.54 Year One
• 16.55 Year Two
• 16.56 Year Three
• 16.57 Year Four
• 16.58 What Success Looks Like
• 16.59 What We Should Avoid

Every city needs a place where the community can simply gather.

Not only for major festivals.

Not only for organized events.

Not only when someone has rented a hall.

A civic gathering place should also work on an ordinary Tuesday.

A place to sit.

Meet someone.

Have lunch.

Listen to music.

Visit the market.

Attend a ceremony.

Watch a performance.

Bring children.

Join a public meeting.

Celebrate.

Remember.

Demonstrate peacefully.

Spend time downtown without being required to purchase something.

The existing proposal identifies the City Hall and market area as an opportunity to create a stronger civic square serving markets, events, performances and ordinary public life.

The objective should not be to begin with a large construction project.

It should be to begin with the place we already have and ask:

How much more community life could happen here if we organized it properly?

The Civic Square should therefore be developed according to one principle:

Program first. Test the space. Learn what people use. Build permanent infrastructure only when the evidence supports it.

This is not a proposal for an expensive monument.

It is a proposal for a useful public place.

16.1Why a Civic Square

Cities need common ground.

Homes are private.

Businesses are commercial.

Churches and organizations serve particular communities.

A civic square is different.

It is one of the places where everyone can belong at the same time.

That makes it valuable for:

• civic events;
• markets;
• cultural events;
• youth activities;
• music;
• public meetings;
• ceremonies;
• festivals;
• family activity;
• seniors;
• visitors;
• peaceful public expression.

A successful civic square strengthens downtown because people who come for one reason may:

• visit a restaurant;
• shop;
• walk the river;
• visit another business;
• return later.

But economic activity should be a benefit of the square, not the condition for using it.

A civic square should remain public first.

16.2Start With What We Already Own

The first question should not be:

What should we build?

It should be:

What public space do we already own, and how effectively are we using it?

The City Hall and market area already provide a natural civic location.

Before considering major construction, examine:

• existing pavement;
• sidewalks;
• seating;
• shade;
• trees;
• parking;
• electrical service;
• water;
• washrooms;
• storage;
• accessibility;
• nearby buildings;
• traffic;
• loading;
• snow removal;
• event access.

Some improvements may be surprisingly inexpensive.

A few practical changes could produce substantial new use.

16.3The Pilot-First Rule

The Civic Square should begin as a pilot program, not a permanent redesign.

Use temporary infrastructure to learn.

Examples could include:

• movable tables;
• movable chairs;
• umbrellas;
• temporary shade;
• planters;
• temporary stage equipment;
• portable power;
• temporary lighting;
• removable barriers;
• games;
• seasonal decorations.

Then observe.

Ask

Where do people sit?

Where do families gather?

Where does shade matter?

Where does sound work?

Where are accessibility problems?

Where do vendors need power?

Where do deliveries need to move?

Where does emergency access need to remain?

Where does snow accumulate?

Where do residents naturally walk?

Design should follow use.

Not the other way around.

16.4A Square That Works Without an Event

A public square that feels empty unless an event is scheduled has not fully succeeded.

The space should support ordinary use.

That may mean providing:

• comfortable seating;
• tables;
• shade;
• trees;
• public washroom access;
• drinking water where feasible;
• bicycle parking;
• accessible routes;
• clear wayfinding;
• Wi-Fi where appropriate;
• nearby food options;
• simple public activities.

The Tuesday Test

Visit the square on an ordinary weekday when nothing special is happening.

Ask:

Would I choose to spend twenty minutes here?

If the answer is no, understand why.

Events should animate a good space.

They should not be required to hide a bad one.

16.5Flexible Space

The Civic Square should be designed for many uses rather than one specialized use.

A permanent feature that works beautifully twice a year but obstructs every other activity may not be a good investment.

The square should be able to shift between:

• market;
• concert;
• public ceremony;
• children's event;
• yoga;
• public meeting;
• food event;
• arts activity;
• holiday programming;
• quiet everyday use.

Movable Before Permanent

Where practical, begin with movable:

• furniture;
• planters;
• shade;
• stage elements;
• event equipment.

Flexibility allows the community to discover what works before City Hall decides what everyone needs.

16.6The Market

The market should remain one of the natural anchors of the Civic Square concept.

Markets create repeated community activity.

They bring together:

• farmers;
• food producers;
• artisans;
• makers;
• residents;
• visitors;
• downtown businesses.

The Civic Square should support market activity without becoming useful only during market hours.

Market Infrastructure Could Include

• vendor access;
• power;
• water where required;
• waste and recycling;
• washrooms;
• weather protection;
• seating;
• loading;
• storage;
• signage.

Complement Downtown Businesses

The market should strengthen nearby businesses rather than operate as though the surrounding downtown does not exist.

Event promotion can help visitors understand:

The market is one part of the downtown experience.

That can encourage people to remain longer and explore surrounding streets.

16.7Food

Food makes public spaces work.

The Civic Square could accommodate appropriate food activity through:

• market vendors;
• food trucks;
• temporary food events;
• nearby restaurants;
• patios;
• community organizations.

Food service must comply with applicable:

• public-health requirements;
• fire requirements;
• licensing;
• waste management;
• event rules.

Do Not Over-Regulate Small Events

The City should make requirements easy to understand.

An organization hosting a small community food event should be able to find one clear checklist explaining what is required.

16.8Stage Capability

The Civic Square should be able to support performances without requiring a major stage to remain permanently installed.

A modest stage system could support:

• musicians;
• speeches;
• school performances;
• theatre;
• ceremonies;
• public debates;
• cultural events.

First Determine the Need

Before purchasing permanent infrastructure, measure:

• number of events;
• size of events;
• sound requirements;
• setup cost;
• rental cost;
• storage;
• staffing.

A modular stage may provide better value than a permanent structure.

Permanent Infrastructure Later

If several years of use demonstrate strong demand, then consider whether a permanent stage or performance structure is justified.

Use should create the business case.

16.9Power

Events frequently need electricity.

Temporary generators can create:

• noise;
• fumes;
• cables;
• accessibility hazards;
• additional setup.

If the Civic Square becomes a regular event space, properly designed permanent electrical connections may be one of the most useful infrastructure investments.

Power Planning Should Consider

• vendor use;
• stage sound;
• lighting;
• seasonal events;
• safety;
• weather protection;
• capacity;
• future expansion.

Connections should be safely installed and protected from unauthorized use.

The City should know the difference between useful event infrastructure and unnecessary electrical overbuilding.

16.10Water

Access to water can support:

• market operations;
• event cleanup;
• temporary food service;
• drinking-water refill;
• landscaping.

Any public or vendor water supply must be designed and maintained appropriately.

Drinking Water

Where practical, include a public bottle-refill opportunity.

That provides a simple service to:

• residents;
• cyclists;
• walkers;
• families;
• visitors.

The same amenity supports the future Owen Sound Outside program.

16.11Public Washrooms

A civic square without practical washroom access will always be limited.

Before investing in event infrastructure, identify the washroom plan.

Options might include:

• existing nearby public facilities;
• improved access to municipal facilities;
• permanent public washroom infrastructure;
• temporary facilities during large events;
• partnerships.

The Washroom Standard

Residents should know:

• location;
• hours;
• accessibility;
• seasonal availability.

For events, organizers should know whether additional facilities are required.

Public washrooms should be treated as core civic infrastructure, not an afterthought.

16.12Accessibility

The Civic Square should aim to become one of the easiest public spaces in Owen Sound for people of different abilities to use.

Accessibility should influence:

• route design;
• surface;
• seating;
• stage viewing;
• washrooms;
• parking;
• drop-off;
• signs;
• sound;
• event layout;
• snow clearing.

Ask People Who Use the Space Differently

Involve residents who experience:

• mobility barriers;
• visual barriers;
• hearing barriers;
• sensory barriers;
• cognitive barriers.

A design can meet a technical minimum and still be unpleasant or difficult to use.

Lived experience matters.

16.13Accessible Events

Event organizers using Civic Square should receive a simple accessibility checklist.

Questions could include:

• Is there an accessible route?
• Can someone using a mobility device reach seating?
• Is accessible seating integrated rather than isolated?
• Is information readable?
• Are washrooms accessible?
• Are cables protected?
• Is sound reasonable?
• Is an accessible drop-off available?
• Is event information available in an accessible format where practical?

The objective should be help, not bureaucracy.

A good checklist prevents barriers before they are built into the event layout.

16.14Seating

Movable seating should play an important role.

Permanent benches are useful.

Movable chairs provide choice.

A resident may want:

• sun;
• shade;
• quiet;
• conversation;
• a view of the stage;
• space beside a mobility device;
• room for a stroller.

Different Seating Types

The square could gradually include:

• benches;
• chairs;
• tables;
• picnic tables;
• accessible tables;
• seat walls where appropriate.

Not everyone can comfortably sit on the same type of furniture.

Variety improves use.

16.15Shade

Summer public space requires shade.

That can come from:

• trees;
• umbrellas;
• temporary structures;
• permanent structures.

The pilot phase should show where shade is actually required.

Trees First Where Appropriate

Trees provide long-term value but require:

• soil;
• water;
• maintenance;
• appropriate species selection;
• adequate root space.

Plant them where they can thrive.

Do not install trees simply as decorative objects and then replace them every few years because the planting conditions were poor.

16.16Weather

A four-season Canadian civic square has to deal with:

• rain;
• wind;
• sun;
• snow;
• ice;
• cold.

Weather should influence design.

Summer

Provide:

• shade;
• water;
• seating;
• evening activity.

Spring and Autumn

Consider:

• wind;
• rain shelter;
• drainage;
• movable furniture.

Winter

Consider:

• snow storage;
• clearing routes;
• lighting;
• winter events;
• seating where practical;
• seasonal installations.

Design for the actual climate of Owen Sound.

16.17Winter Civic Square

The Civic Square should not close mentally in October.

Winter programming could include:

• lights;
• markets;
• music;
• warming events;
• public art;
• winter food events;
• holiday programming;
• family activities;
• snow sculptures;
• outdoor exercise;
• seasonal gatherings.

Where safe and practical, the square could also support connections to nearby skating or winter recreation programs.

Canadian Winter as an Asset

Winter programming should be designed around the season rather than attempting to recreate summer outside in February.

The objective is:

Give people a reason to come together during the time of year when isolation can be greatest.

16.18Children's Use

Children make public spaces feel different.

They bring:

• movement;
• noise;
• families;
• repeat visits.

The Civic Square does not necessarily require a full playground.

It can support temporary activities such as:

• giant games;
• chalk;
• building blocks;
• simple water play where appropriate;
• art;
• seasonal activities;
• story time.

Design for Parents Too

Where children are invited, provide:

• seating;
• shade;
• washrooms;
• safe sightlines.

A family space works better when the adult supervising the child is comfortable too.

16.19Youth Use

Teenagers and young adults should also feel welcome.

Public space should not communicate:

You belong here only when adults have programmed something for you.

Possible youth activity could include:

• student music;
• art;
• dance;
• markets;
• chess;
• gaming events;
• youth entrepreneurship;
• Civic Corps presentations;
• outdoor study or social areas.

Youth should have input into the square's programming.

16.20Seniors

The Civic Square should work for older residents.

That means considering:

• stable seating;
• shade;
• washrooms;
• accessible parking;
• smooth routes;
• clear signs;
• snow clearing;
• transit access.

Senior Programming

Possible activities could include:

• music;
• walking groups;
• markets;
• public talks;
• gentle exercise;
• community lunches;
• intergenerational events.

The square should support social connection without requiring high physical ability.

16.21Public Art

The Civic Square can become an important location for public art.

Permanent work should be selected carefully.

Temporary work allows more experimentation.

Possible forms include:

• sculpture;
• mural;
• light installations;
• student art;
• Indigenous art developed through appropriate partnership;
• seasonal art;
• interactive installations.

Temporary Art Program

An annual temporary-art program could allow the square to change over time.

That creates opportunities for more artists without permanently filling every available public space.

16.22Music

Small-scale live music should become normal.

Not every performance requires:

• a street closure;
• large sound system;
• beer garden;
• security plan.

The City should make it relatively simple to host suitable small performances.

Music Calendar

Possible recurring programming:

• lunchtime music;
• Friday evening performances;
• student showcases;
• Sunday afternoon music;
• market performances.

The City does not need to produce every event.

It can create the platform and let community organizations use it.

16.23Public Speaking and Debate

A civic square should be capable of hosting civic discussion.

That might include:

• candidate events;
• public debates;
• community forums;
• issue discussions;
• public presentations.

City Hall should not control public thought merely because the square is municipally owned.

Booking rules should be viewpoint-neutral and applied consistently.

16.24Peaceful Demonstration

A genuine civic square must accommodate peaceful public expression.

Residents may gather to:

• support government;
• criticize government;
• advocate for a cause;
• protest a decision;
• commemorate an event.

Municipal rules should focus on legitimate matters such as:

• safety;
• access;
• noise;
• property protection;
• competing bookings.

They should not be used to suppress criticism because the criticism is uncomfortable.

A public square that welcomes celebration but not peaceful disagreement is not fully civic.

16.25Faith and Cultural Events

Faith communities and cultural organizations should be able to use the square under fair booking rules.

Examples might include:

• music;
• cultural festivals;
• public ceremonies;
• holiday events;
• charitable activity;
• community meals.

Equal Access

The City should neither exclude a group because it is religious nor grant special access simply because it is religious.

The same general public-space rules should apply.

Municipal participation should respect Canadian constitutional and human-rights obligations while allowing residents to bring their full identities into community life.

16.26Indigenous Partnership

Where Saugeen Ojibway Nation wishes to participate, the Civic Square could become a place for:

• cultural events;
• education;
• art;
• ceremony;
• community relationship.

The City should not design Indigenous content on behalf of Indigenous communities.

Ask.

Listen.

Partner where welcomed.

That principle should govern all related programming.

16.27Markets Beyond Food

The square could support specialized markets such as:

• makers;
• artists;
• students;
• books;
• second-hand goods;
• holiday vendors;
• local manufacturers;
• repair events.

Student Market

A recurring youth entrepreneurship market could allow students to sell:

• art;
• crafts;
• products;
• food where compliant;
• services.

This connects the Civic Square directly to future youth and business-development programs.

16.28Local Manufacturers

The square could periodically showcase products manufactured in:

• Owen Sound;
• Grey Bruce;
• Ontario;
• Canada.

This would connect the civic space with the enthusiast economy and Canadian purchasing themes elsewhere in the plan.

For example:

Made Here Weekend

could feature local and Canadian:

• outdoor equipment;
• food;
• manufactured products;
• tools;
• recreation products;
• technology.

The City provides the place.

Businesses provide the products.

16.29Repair Events

A practical community event could involve qualified people helping residents learn how to repair or maintain:

• bicycles;
• small household items;
• clothing;
• outdoor equipment.

Where professional or regulated work is involved, appropriate safety and qualification standards apply.

The point is to create a culture that values:

• maintenance;
• repair;
• reuse;
• skills.

That aligns with the City's broader stewardship philosophy.

16.30Recreation

The Civic Square can become a starting point for recreation rather than only a destination.

Possible activities:

• walking groups;
• downtown history walks;
• river walks;
• cycling starts;
• yoga;
• stretching;
• wellness programs.

This will connect directly with Owen Sound Outside later in the plan.

Meet Here

A resident should increasingly see the Civic Square as a natural answer to:

Where should we meet?

That is a powerful sign that a public place is working.

16.31Community Organizations

Local organizations need affordable places to reach the public.

The square could provide opportunities for:

• service clubs;
• charities;
• sports organizations;
• cultural groups;
• volunteer organizations;
• neighbourhood groups.

Community Information Days

Rather than every organization holding a separate event, occasional shared community days could bring many groups together.

That helps residents discover opportunities they did not know existed.

16.32The Community Calendar

Every approved public Civic Square event should connect automatically to the future community calendar.

Residents should be able to see:

• what;
• when;
• where;
• cost;
• accessibility;
• weather status where relevant.

The same calendar should eventually serve events throughout Owen Sound.

Do not create a separate application for every public program.

Build one understandable system.

16.33Booking Rules

A public square needs clear booking rules.

The rules should be:

• simple;
• public;
• consistent;
• viewpoint-neutral.

Booking Information Should Explain

• who can book;
• available dates;
• permitted uses;
• fees;
• insurance requirements;
• alcohol rules;
• food requirements;
• electrical access;
• sound limits;
• waste responsibilities;
• cleanup;
• cancellation;
• weather;
• accessibility;
• emergency access.

Small Event Versus Large Event

A five-person community table should not face the same process as a festival for several thousand people.

Create proportional requirements.

The bigger the event and risk, the stronger the planning requirements.

16.34Fees

Some Civic Square uses should be free.

Others may reasonably carry a fee.

Possible factors include:

• commercial use;
• exclusive use;
• City staff required;
• cleanup;
• power;
• equipment;
• security;
• special setup.

Public Benefit

Community organizations and non-commercial public activities may justify reduced or waived fees under clear criteria.

The subsidy should be transparent.

Do not create a system where fees depend on whether the organizer knows somebody at City Hall.

16.35Commercial Use

Commercial activity can add life to the square.

It must remain balanced with public access.

A business might use the square for:

• market sales;
• product demonstrations;
• food;
• ticketed events.

Public Space Remains Public

Commercial bookings should not gradually transform the entire square into private space.

Maintain a reasonable balance between:

• community use;
• commercial use;
• open public use.

Public land should continue to feel public.

16.36Alcohol

Some events may seek licensed alcohol service.

Any alcohol activity must comply with applicable Ontario law, licensing, municipal policies, insurance and public-safety requirements.

The Civic Square should also host many events where alcohol plays no role.

A successful public space should work for:

• families;
• youth;
• seniors;
• people who do not drink;
• people attending licensed events.

No single event type should define the space.

16.37Sound

Music and events create sound.

Downtown residents live nearby.

That means sound rules need to be predictable.

Event Sound Rules Should Address

• hours;
• amplification;
• orientation of speakers;
• event size;
• residential impact.

The rules should be known before an event is booked.

A business or resident should not need to fight the same argument every weekend.

16.38Emergency Access

No event should block required emergency access.

Civic Square planning should identify permanent emergency routes before programming begins.

Event organizers should understand:

• fire access;
• ambulance access;
• evacuation;
• crowd management;
• emergency contact.

This is one reason flexible, movable infrastructure is preferable during the pilot phase.

16.39Loading and Setup

Events require:

• tents;
• tables;
• sound equipment;
• food;
• merchandise.

The square needs a practical loading system.

Establish

• loading area;
• loading times;
• vehicle restrictions;
• setup routes;
• teardown rules.

This reduces conflict between:

• pedestrians;
• vehicles;
• businesses;
• event organizers.

16.40Waste

A successful event creates waste.

The organizer and City should know beforehand:

• how many bins are needed;
• who empties them;
• recycling arrangements;
• food-waste management where applicable;
• post-event cleanup.

Leave It Better

Event organizers should be expected to leave the space reasonably clean.

City crews should not become the unpaid cleanup service for poorly managed private events.

16.41Storage

Tables, chairs, stage equipment, electrical equipment and event supplies require storage.

Do not purchase large amounts of equipment before identifying:

• where it will be stored;
• who manages it;
• who maintains it;
• how it is booked;
• who inspects it.

The No Hidden Liability Rule applies here too.

A chair bought for $100 can require twenty years of:

• storage;
• handling;
• repair;
• replacement.

Small infrastructure still needs ownership.

16.42Shared Event Equipment

Instead of every community organization purchasing the same equipment, the City could maintain or coordinate access to selected shared items.

Possibilities include:

• tables;
• chairs;
• barricades;
• portable stage pieces;
• tents;
• accessible cable covers;
• signage.

The business case should compare:

• purchase;
• rental;
• storage;
• maintenance;
• staff handling.

Shared ownership makes sense only where equipment is used enough to justify it.

16.43Partners

The Civic Square should operate through partnership.

Potential partners might include:

• downtown businesses;
• market vendors;
• churches;
• service clubs;
• arts organizations;
• schools;
• youth groups;
• seniors' organizations;
• cultural groups;
• sports organizations;
• community charities.

The City should provide the public framework.

Community partners should provide much of the activity.

Government does not need to become an event-production company.

16.44Sponsorship

Sponsors may help support:

• events;
• furniture;
• temporary installations;
• equipment;
• programming.

Sponsorship should follow the principles already established in the City's Financial Standard.

Sponsorship Cannot Purchase

• regulatory advantage;
• procurement preference;
• political influence;
• resident data;
• permanent ownership of public space.

Recognition should remain proportional.

The square should not become covered in advertising.

16.45No Advertising Surveillance

Free public Wi-Fi or digital event services should not require residents to surrender unnecessary personal information.

Do not make access conditional on:

• marketing consent;
• political profiling;
• commercial tracking.

If Wi-Fi is offered, collect only what is necessary for safe operation.

Public infrastructure should not become a hidden data-harvesting system.

16.46Safety

A public square should feel safe without becoming over-controlled.

Safety can be supported by:

• lighting;
• visibility;
• regular activity;
• maintenance;
• clear rules;
• staff presence during major events;
• emergency planning.

Police should be involved when police authority is required.

Most ordinary civic-square activity should not require a police presence.

A healthy public place is made safer partly because people are using it.

16.47Lighting

Lighting should support:

• evening use;
• accessibility;
• security;
• winter activity;
• events.

It can also help create character.

Seasonal lighting can make the space inviting during winter.

Permanent lighting should be:

• efficient;
• maintainable;
• respectful of nearby residents;
• appropriate to heritage context.

The pilot phase should show where additional lighting is actually needed.

16.48Heritage and City Hall

The Civic Square should respect the architectural and civic significance of the City Hall area.

Any permanent changes should consider:

• heritage;
• sightlines;
• architecture;
• existing public functions.

The objective is not to cover a historic civic setting with temporary-looking permanent infrastructure.

Permanent elements should be compatible with the place.

Temporary programming can be more playful.

16.49City Hall Should Open Toward the Square

A civic square beside City Hall creates an opportunity to make municipal government feel more visible and approachable.

Possible programming could include:

• Council information days;
• public budget discussions;
• infrastructure displays;
• civic education;
• public scorecard presentations;
• student municipal events.

Government should occasionally come outside the building.

Mayor's Community Assembly

The annual Mayor's Community Assembly developed in Section 5 could be held in the Civic Square when weather and accessibility permit.

Residents should see City Hall not only as a building where decisions occur, but as part of the public space where government meets the community.

16.50No Campaign Square

The Civic Square must not become a publicly funded extension of the Mayor's political campaign.

City events should use:

• municipal branding;
• neutral public information;
• normal public-service standards.

No:

• campaign fundraising;
• campaign advertising;
• candidate mailing lists;
• political data collection.

During election periods, use of the square by candidates should follow the same applicable public rules available to other candidates.

Public infrastructure belongs to the City.

Not the office-holder.

16.51Measurement

Before making major permanent investments, measure use.

Possible measures include:

Activity

• event days;
• event attendance where reasonably estimated;
• market use;
• ordinary daily use at selected times.

Diversity of Use

• family events;
• youth events;
• seniors' activity;
• cultural events;
• commercial markets;
• civic events.

Business

• nearby business feedback;
• event-day effects.

Accessibility

• barriers identified;
• improvements made.

Operations

• setup cost;
• cleanup;
• damage;
• staff time;
• washroom use;
• power use.

Resident Opinion

• satisfaction;
• concerns;
• desired changes.

Numbers should help answer:

What should we improve next?

They should not be manipulated to prove the square was automatically successful because City Hall created it.

16.52Public Feedback During the Pilot

During the first seasons, make feedback easy.

A small sign could ask:

What would make you use this space more often?

Residents could respond:

• online;
• paper;
• at City Hall;
• during events.

Ask practical questions.

Not:

"Do you support the Civic Square?"

Ask:

• More shade?
• More seating?
• Better washrooms?
• Music?
• Children's activities?
• Winter programming?
• More market days?
• Quieter programming?
• Different hours?

Design improves when questions are specific.

16.53The First 100 Days

The Civic Square should begin with observation and inexpensive action.

1. Site Walk

Bring together:

• City operations;
• market representatives;
• downtown businesses;
• residents;
• accessibility representatives;
• event organizers.

2. Asset Inventory

Identify:

• electrical;
• water;
• washrooms;
• seating;
• storage;
• lighting;
• shade;
• loading;
• parking;
• emergency access.

3. Accessibility Review

Identify immediate barriers.

4. Event Review

Examine the last several years of events held in or around the area.

Ask:

• What infrastructure was rented repeatedly?
• What problems occurred repeatedly?
• What did organizers wish existed?

5. Pilot Layout

Create several temporary configurations.

6. Cost Them

Publish the pilot cost.

7. Establish Booking Rules

Before programming expands.

8. Publish the Calendar

Make activity easy to find.

16.54Year One

During Year One:

• launch a low-cost Civic Square pilot;
• add movable seating;
• improve wayfinding;
• confirm washroom access;
• identify power requirements;
• test small performances;
• expand market programming where appropriate;
• test youth and family activities;
• establish booking rules;
• establish event accessibility standards;
• gather resident and business feedback;
• measure use;
• identify what permanent improvements, if any, deserve consideration.

Year One Rule

Do not pour expensive permanent infrastructure because the pilot looked good during one festival.

Observe a full season.

Preferably four seasons.

16.55Year Two

Based on evidence:

• improve successful layouts;
• add necessary electrical connections;
• improve water access where justified;
• improve seating;
• add shade;
• improve lighting;
• improve storage;
• strengthen winter programming;
• grow recurring small events;
• connect programming to river and downtown initiatives.

If a proposed improvement lacks demonstrated use, defer it.

16.56Year Three

By Year Three, the City should know much more about how the space actually functions.

This is the appropriate time to consider whether more substantial capital investment is justified.

Possible permanent improvements might include:

• durable electrical infrastructure;
• washroom improvements;
• permanent shade;
• landscape improvements;
• improved surfaces;
• accessible design;
• modest permanent performance infrastructure.

Any substantial project should pass the Financial Standard and lifecycle test.

16.57Year Four

By Year Four, Civic Square should have one of three outcomes.

Successful Permanent Civic Space

Usage supports continued investment and a mature program.

Successful Low-Cost Flexible Space

The pilot proves that temporary and movable infrastructure is actually the better long-term model.

Limited Demand

The City determines that more substantial investment is not justified.

All three outcomes are acceptable.

A pilot that prevents an unnecessary capital project has succeeded.

16.58What Success Looks Like

The success of the Civic Square should not be measured by how much money the City spends.

Ask instead:

Do people use it when no major event is happening?

Do families feel welcome?

Can seniors use it comfortably?

Can a person using a mobility device participate?

Are washrooms practical?

Is it active in more than one season?

Are businesses benefiting or being harmed?

Can small organizations afford to use it?

Are performers using it?

Does the market work better?

Can residents gather there for civic discussion?

Can someone peacefully criticize City Hall there?

Is maintenance sustainable?

Can the City afford what it has created?

If yes, the square is working.

16.59What We Should Avoid

The Civic Square should not become:

• a massive capital project before demand is proven;
• a permanent festival site that is empty most of the year;
• a commercial mall on public land;
• a political stage controlled by the Mayor;
• an advertising platform;
• an inaccessible gathering place;
• a summer-only space;
• an event program requiring unsustainable City staffing;
• a collection of equipment nobody maintains;
• a public space where ordinary residents feel they need permission to sit.

The square should remain simple enough to adapt.

The Civic Square Commitment

The City Hall and market area already belong to the people of Owen Sound.

The question is whether we can make that public space work harder for them.

The commitment is:

Use what we already own before building more.

Start with temporary and movable infrastructure.

Test the space through all four seasons.

Provide seating, shade and practical amenities.

Plan washrooms before major programming.

Make accessibility part of the design from the beginning.

Support the market.

Create opportunities for music, art, youth, families and seniors.

Allow peaceful civic expression.

Make booking rules fair and understandable.

Keep campaign politics separate from municipal space.

Measure actual use.

Invest permanently only after the community proves what it needs.

The best Civic Square will not be the one City Hall designs most impressively on paper.

It will be the one residents quietly begin using as though it has always belonged to them.

Because it does.

Create the place. Invite the community. Watch how they use it. Then build only what makes the place better.